League One, 42-round, regular season, 01.04.2024 10:00
Exeter City 1 - 0 Cheltenham Town, League One, 8-round, 16.09.23
Exeter City 0 - 1 Cheltenham Town, League One, 5-round, 20.08.22
Exeter City 0 - 1 Cheltenham Town, League Two, 36-round, 13.03.21
Cheltenham Town 5 - 3 Exeter City, League Two, 16-round, 05.12.20