League One, 32-round, regular season, 14.02.2023 13:45
Plymouth Argyle 1 - 0 Oxford United, League One, 41-round, 02.04.22
Oxford United 3 - 1 Plymouth Argyle, League One, 44-round, 24.04.21
Plymouth Argyle 2 - 3 Oxford United, League One, 21-round, 29.12.20